Top5it.net
The Top 5 of anything

Good research. Real opinions.

Browse buying guides Home & YardAll buying guides & advice

Soy-based pumpkin candles.

Five pumpkin-scented jar candles made with soy wax or a disclosed soy-based blend. Compare the fragrance notes, actual wax fill and vessel before choosing. Brand burn-time estimates are not independently measured results.

Compare the five picks

Research shortlist: AI-assisted research. We haven’t personally tested these products.

Swipe to see the full comparison →

Soy-based pumpkin candles: five research recommendations
RecommendationConsider forKey detailObserved cost · USD
01P.F. CANDLE CO.Spiced Pumpkin · Standard 7.2 ozA compact pure-soy starting point100% soy wax · 7.2 oz
Check current priceCheck Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.
02BROOKLYN CANDLE STUDIOToasted Pumpkin · 13 oz, 2-wickA larger jar with a spice-led fragrance profile100% soy wax · 13 oz
Check current priceView source ↗
03MILKHOUSE CANDLE CO.Brown Butter Pumpkin · 7 oz Classic StatementA smaller jar with dessert-style fragrance notesNatural soy wax · paraffin-free · 7 oz
Check current priceCheck Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.
04CALYAN WAX CO.Pumpkin + Spices · Glass Tumbler, 8.8 oz waxA two-wick tumbler with a wooden lid100% soy wax · stated fill 8.8 oz
Check current priceCheck Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.
05SWEET WATER DECORPumpkin Spice · 9 oz Amber Jar, C103AAn amber-jar option if a soy blend suits youSoy-based wax blend · 208 g net
Check current priceCheck Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.

Dated seller observations, not live quotes. Prices can change; tax and delivery are extra. Match the exact package shown below.

Compare the wax, then follow the candle label

Soy-based does not necessarily mean 100% soy: blends are identified above. Wax type alone does not establish allergy suitability, indoor-air safety or scent strength. Follow each candle’s label, keep the flame at least 12 inches from anything that can burn, use a stable heat-resistant surface and keep children and pets away. Extinguish candles before leaving the room or sleeping. Burn times depend on use; never treat them as a reason to exceed the maker’s session limit.

U.S. Fire Administration: candle fire safety
01

P.F. CANDLE CO.

Spiced Pumpkin · Standard 7.2 oz

A compact pure-soy starting point

Research pick
P.F. CANDLE CO. Spiced Pumpkin · Standard 7.2 ozPhoto: P.F. Candle Co. · manufacturer product photograph
Cost to compareCheck current price

Check Amazon for the current price of the Spiced Pumpkin Standard Candle, 7.2 oz amber jar with brass lid; 100% soy wax, not another fragrance or size.

Check Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.

A straightforward first comparison if you want a smaller amber jar and a clearly disclosed wax. The brand describes a buttery pumpkin fragrance with nutmeg and brown sugar; this is a description of its fragrance recipe, not our impression after burning it.

  • 100% soy wax · 7.2 oz
  • Cotton-core wick; amber glass and lid
  • Brand estimate: 40–50 hours
The tradeoff

Limited edition. The brand positions its scent as subtle to moderate, so do not assume it will fill a large open room. Confirm seasonal stock before ordering.

View on Amazon

Amazon affiliate link · We may earn a commission. Manufacturer specifications ↗

02

BROOKLYN CANDLE STUDIO

Toasted Pumpkin · 13 oz, 2-wick

A larger jar with a spice-led fragrance profile

Research pick
BROOKLYN CANDLE STUDIO Toasted Pumpkin · 13 oz, 2-wickPhoto: Brooklyn Candle Studio · manufacturer product photograph
Cost to compareCheck current price

An exact-package price has not been verified yet. Check what is included before comparing.

View source ↗

The two-wick format gives you a larger candle to compare with the compact jars here. Its published notes emphasize cardamom, cinnamon, clove and toasted pumpkin. Choose on those notes and the 13-ounce format rather than assuming two wicks guarantee stronger fragrance.

  • 100% soy wax · 13 oz
  • Two cotton wicks; glass tumbler
  • Brand estimate: up to 70 hours
The tradeoff

A larger vessel needs more clear surface space and two wicks to maintain. The seasonal edition and fragrance notes may not suit someone seeking a simple sweet pumpkin-pie scent.

View product
03

MILKHOUSE CANDLE CO.

Brown Butter Pumpkin · 7 oz Classic Statement

A smaller jar with dessert-style fragrance notes

Research pick
MILKHOUSE CANDLE CO. Brown Butter Pumpkin · 7 oz Classic StatementPhoto: Milkhouse Candle Co. · manufacturer product photograph
Cost to compareCheck current price

Check Amazon for the current price of the Milkhouse Brown Butter Pumpkin 7oz/198g Classic Statement jar with silver metal lid,33+hour burn; not10oz Signature,16/22oz Butter Jar or wax melt.

Check Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.

This is the compact Classic Statement glass jar, with a metal lid and cotton wick. Its published fragrance combines pumpkin, browned butter, toasted spice and vanilla cream. It is a useful alternative to a larger two-wick candle when shelf space matters.

  • Natural soy wax · paraffin-free · 7 oz
  • Cotton wick; glass jar with metal lid
  • Brand estimate: 33+ hours
The tradeoff

The smaller fill has a shorter stated burn window than the larger options. The sweet, creamy fragrance description is not a measured indication of throw or a promise of how it will smell in your room.

View on Amazon

Amazon affiliate link · We may earn a commission. Manufacturer specifications ↗

04

CALYAN WAX CO.

Pumpkin + Spices · Glass Tumbler, 8.8 oz wax

A two-wick tumbler with a wooden lid

Research pick
CALYAN WAX CO. Pumpkin + Spices · Glass Tumbler, 8.8 oz waxPhoto: Calyan Wax Co. · manufacturer product photograph
Cost to compareCheck current price

Check Amazon for the current price of the Calyan Wax Co Pumpkin & Spices 2-wick 8.8oz glass tumbler,37hour burn,one-time purchase; not3-wick14.9oz or different fragrance.

Check Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.

Calyan pairs a reusable glass tumbler with two cotton wicks and a wooden lid. The stated scent notes lean toward pumpkin, brown sugar, caramel and vanilla. We use the current product-details wax fill rather than treating the page’s older 11-ounce title as net wax weight.

  • 100% soy wax · stated fill 8.8 oz
  • Two cotton wicks; wooden lid
  • Brand estimate: up to 37 hours
The tradeoff

The page title and current wax-fill specification differ; verify the supplied label before buying. Two wicks and a bigger-looking vessel do not guarantee a longer burn than a smaller single-wick jar.

View on Amazon

Amazon affiliate link · We may earn a commission. Manufacturer specifications ↗

05

SWEET WATER DECOR

Pumpkin Spice · 9 oz Amber Jar, C103A

An amber-jar option if a soy blend suits you

Research pick
SWEET WATER DECOR Pumpkin Spice · 9 oz Amber Jar, C103APhoto: Sweet Water Decor · manufacturer product photograph
Cost to compareCheck current price

Check Amazon for the current price of the Pumpkin Spice C103A candle, 9oz amber glass jar with black lid, 208g net wax; soy wax blend, not Hello Pumpkin or gold-lid version.

Check Amazon price ↗Affiliate link · We may earn a commission.

A compact amber jar with pumpkin, clove, cinnamon and vanilla notes, plus buttercream and smoky notes in the fragrance description. The maker explicitly identifies a proprietary soy-based blend. Its 9-ounce designation is jar volume; the page separately lists 208 grams net weight.

  • Soy-based wax blend · 208 g net
  • 9 oz jar volume · cotton wick · C103A
  • Brand estimate: 40+ hours
The tradeoff

The soy percentage and other wax components are not disclosed. Choose another pick if you require a 100% soy wax base. A shipping-date notice on the page is ambiguous, so confirm dispatch timing before ordering.

View on Amazon

Amazon affiliate link · We may earn a commission. Manufacturer specifications ↗

Owner opinions

Loading owner opinions…

Know what’s behind a pick.

Linked product sources, clear tradeoffs and no paid placements. No fabricated votes.

Last researched: October 25, 2026

A SHORTER LIST. A BIGGER CONVERSATION.

What deserves a spot?